The Fairbairn Sykes Fighting Knives
  • Home Page
    • The Beginning
    • Modern Warrior
    • End of an Era?
    • Fighting Knives For Sale
    • commando knives for sale
    • Recommended Reading
  • WW-II Commando Knives
    • Rarest of Them All
    • X-Daggers
    • First Pattern >
      • Examples
    • Second Pattern >
      • Standard P-2
      • Nickle, Silver, & Gold
      • Beaded & Ribbed
      • Fatman Knives
      • Named Knives
    • Third Pattern >
      • Nickle plated P-3
      • Wilkinson P-3
      • FR693
    • French Commando Knives
    • Variants >
      • knuckle knives
      • Wood Hilted Knives
      • Leather Hilted
      • Stag Hilted
      • Cast & Alloy Hilts
      • Cutlery Handles
    • Australian Knives
  • Derivative knives
    • Odds N Ends
    • USMC & OSS Stiletto
    • Geber & Randall
    • EK Knives
    • Case V-42
    • Post WW-II Versions
    • Custom F~S Knives
    • Commemoratives
  • Agent's Daggers
    • Smatchets & Kukri
    • Thumb Daggers etc.
    • Capt. Peter Mason
    • Shanghai daggers
  • The Stories
    • Our Family Stories
  • Minutiae
    • Sheaths >
      • Field Expedient
      • Sheath Minutae
    • Inspection Stamps
    • Blade Etches
    • Top nuts
  • Contact Us & Links
    • Combined Military Services Museum
    • What is it? Who made it?
    • About Us
  • Blog

A Broken Beasley

6/19/2022

0 Comments

 
Picture
Bad Breaks:
 
The question often arises about the suitability and durability of the F~S as a combat knife. Were the WW-II F~S a fragile and undependable knife? Yes and No. At one time I believed the FS was the ultimate fighting knife. I have since outgrown that view, and setting aside the romance, looked at them a bit more realistically.
 
A man who is a skilled knife fighter, knife maker, and X-Special Forces soldier once corrected me. He said “there is no such thing as a knife fight, there is only a killing.” Another person once wisely opined that whatever knife you have in your hand can be, perhaps must be, a fighting knife. If I were forced to make a choice I would now crown the Bowie as the best format for a fighting knife. I would name the F~S as the most effective "killing" knife. An entire book could be written to explain why I say this but let it suffice to say that a skilled knifer will understand the difference in techniques used in defence and offense as compared to those specially honed for killing.
 
To return to the original question of breakage, the narrowness of the F~S blade that makes it such an effective killing knife is also its source of weakness. The F~S was not alone in its reputation for failing at a critical moment. The USMC stiletto also had a lot of problems with blades breaking. The blades are only about 1/2 the thickness of the Wilkinson FS. In addition, the handles of the USMC Stiletto were fragile. The USMC had a superior handle shape with flattened oval profile (Just what W. E. Fairbairn wanted) but the handle material was brittle and only got worse with age. Today it is hard to find one that has not disintegrated. We have one USMC Stiletto in our collection in pretty good condition and another one with both sides of the guard broken, shortened to almost nothing, and a broken and re-tipped blade.
 
Perhaps some of the best made WW-II daggers were the OSS stiletto, but some of the early ones had soft blades. The later ones have a brinnell mark in the blade just below the guard to verify the hardness of the blades.  
 
Any dagger is inherently a poor cutting knife so it is very important to be able to slide the blade between the ribs rather than get it stuck cross-wise. Therefore orientation of the knife in the user’s hand was important.  We hear stories of Commandos who either jammed their thumbnails on the guard, or failed to make a lethal strike, because in the dark of night they oriented their knives incorrectly. The thumb plays a major role in orienting the blade so it lies flat-wise in the hand. One option is my favorite guard i requested on my Parkinson knives that have a thumb relief ground into both sides of the guard similar to the guards on some of the X-daggers, or the thumbprint idea used in the famous “Black Devil’s” V-42 Stiletto. V-42s had fragile tips. We own one that had the blade broken trying to pry open a door. The blade was replaced with a British one.
 
Other than the First Pattern F~S my all-time favorite stiletto is the Case V-42. This knife had a thick, needle-tipped, hollow-ground blade. It also had a wide leather-backed guard and a thumb pad ground into the ricasso. None of the reproduction V-42 have come close to matching the excellence of the originals. Apparently no one wants to grind that narrow of a blade with four hollow grinds. It is an awesome knife, the likes of which we'll probably never see produced again. How is it that with all of the technology available today no one will make an accurate reproduction? The closest replica was one made by Case Knife Co. for the American Historical Society around the 1980s. 
 
Getting back to the F~S issue, most of the broken ones I have seen were broken near the tip, rather than at the tang. Despite the tang’s scrawny dimensions and apparent weakness all of the broken knives in my collection are broken at the tip. Now, this may be because any that broke at the tang were either thrown away, or were returned for replacement of the blade. 
 
Urban Legend has it that some of the knives with broken blades were sent back to the manufacturer to be refurbished with a new blade.  This was done on a regular exchange basis. Many later post-war production knives have also suffered bent or broken tips, mostly from abuse. Throwing the knives, or using them to pry with, was, and still is, a sure recipe for disaster. I have seen some war-time knives bent at the guard, again probably from some bored soldier trying to stick it into a tree. 
​
Just when you think you’ve seen it all something new shows up. I jumped at the chance to buy a somewhat run-down Tom Beasley knife from a dealer at a very good price. In the photos he posted there were two dark stains across the blade about ¼ inch below the guard. When it arrived I tried to use some acetone and swabs to clean off the “stain.” Imagine my dismay and surprise to find out the stain was the residue left by silver soldering the blade back together! The black stains were created by the hardened flux. Whomever made the repair was a skilled metal worker. How had this postwar knife suffered a catastrophic failure such as this? I didn’t have a clue. The only thing I can imagine is someone accidentally stepping on the blade at just the wrong spot. The knife was found in an old Vets tool box. I can imagine his anguish at having such a valuable knife broken and, even with the skillful repair, the constant reminder the marks would always leave him of some momentary error that caused the irreversible damage.  
 
This story serves to remind us of the importance of practicing responsible stewardship when in the possession of valuable historical artifacts. We are never the real owners, of these objects, only the temporary keepers of such treasures. It behooves us to treat them well and pass them along to the next generation in as good condition as possible.

Picture
0 Comments

Getting Printed

6/18/2022

2 Comments

 
I have come to the conclusion (again) that the only way to get my books printed is to go the self-publishing route. I am in contact with a printer about 90 miles from here. It looks like to make any profit at all softbound books will be approximately $45 shipped CONUS. (As a friend advised me, the final price will be based on any changes in my costs. With the unpredictable costs of inflation I will keep the price as affordable as possible.)

​This Book on clandestine knives will be 165 pages in full color and 8.5 x 11 inches in size. It is heavily loaded with photos, some full page and a lot of close-ups. Black and white would be a lot cheaper but who would want to buy it? I don't think a book with this many original Clandestine knives could ever be put together again based on the size of my collection.

​When I started to complain to my daughter that I couldn't seem to find any new daggers for sale, she said; "that's because you bought them all." Not quite true, but I have collected quite a few. The last few pages will illustrate some of the current day daggers which I felt were worthy of inclusion. Some items are probably WW-I. A couple are Vietnam era. Some are definitely custom one of a kind while others are more production based. It is a wonderful assortment of weapons used in covert operations. So I am going to try printing a few copies before too much longer and see how well they sell. For several days I have concentrated on editing and re-taking photos that were not good enough. This book is a real feast for the eyes. 
Picture
Here are a few sample pages. I know what I look for in a book on knives, and that is photos of knives! In this book there are photos of thumb daggers, an original OSS crossbow bolt, garrote, hat pins, sleeve daggers, shivs etc. I promise you will not be disappointed.
Picture
Picture
Picture
Hopefully by the end of Summer they will be available for sale in limited quantities. Since I retired from teaching, and inflation came roaring to life, money is something we are learning to live without.
Picture
2 Comments

    Author:

    You can find out more about me on the "Stories" pages. My hobbies have included training in Japanese martial arts, including Kenjutsu, many forms of knife fighting, long range rifles and tactical firearms. I have written several self published books on muzzle-loading firearms, knife-fighting and textbooks on gas engines and compressors. I am working diligently on my 400+ page F-S book.

    Picture

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    December 2021
    October 2021
    January 2021
    November 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.